Sealed suction
Vacuum Wars, inches of water lift · Higher is better
- Dyson V15 Detect124 in
- Shark PowerDetect Clean & Empty Cordless112 in
- Dyson V16 Piston Animal Submarine85 in
- Dyson V12 Detect Slim92 in
We compared four premium and upper-mid cordless sticks from Dyson and Shark on Vacuum Wars' measured sealed suction, carpet deep-clean scores, fog-test filtration results and timed run times, with TechGearLab, RTINGS and several multi-week reviews for surface pickup and ergonomics.
Ad disclosure: we earn a commission on Amazon links, at no cost to you. It never decides our picks. How this works
Best overall
Suits Mixed carpet and hard floors, pets included
Best budget
Suits Carpet and pets, with a self-emptying base
Best premium
Suits Large hard-floor homes with long hair
Best for small homes and stairs
Suits Small homes, stairs and mostly hard floors
From spec sheets and independent tests. The best result in a row is tagged.
| Feature | Dyson V15Best overall | Shark PowerDetect CleanBest budget | Dyson V16Best premium | Dyson V12Best for small homes and stairs |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sealed suctionVacuum Wars, inches of water lift | 124 in Best | 112 in | 85 in | 92 in |
| Carpet deep cleanVacuum Wars score | 100 | 100 | 100 | 96 |
| Run time, Eco / MaxEco rated; Max by Vacuum Wars, TechGearLab et al. | 60 / 9-11 min | 70 / 13 min | 70 / 15 min Best | 60 / 8-10 min |
| Weightcomplete stick; maker and Top Ten Reviews | 6.8 lb | About 8 lb | 3.4 kg (about 7.5 lb) | 5.2 lb Best |
| Bin | 0.77 L | 0.7 qt cup, 2 L base | 0.4 L, ~1.3 L compressed | 0.38 L |
| Empties itselfdock | No: No dock | Yes: 2 L base, about 45 days Best | No: No dock | No: No dock |
| Push-button powerno held trigger | No: Held trigger | Yes: Button | Yes: Button | Yes: Button |
| Noise at MaxVacuum Wars | 76 dB | 82 dB | 74 dB Best | 85 dB |
| Warrantymanufacturer | 2 years | 5 years Best | 2 years | 2 years |
| On Amazon | Check price on Amazon(paid link) for Dyson V15 Detect (opens in a new tab) | Check price on Amazon(paid link) for Shark PowerDetect Clean & Empty Cordless (IP3251) (opens in a new tab) | Check price on Amazon(paid link) for Dyson V16 Piston Animal Submarine (opens in a new tab) | Check price on Amazon(paid link) for Dyson V12 Detect Slim (opens in a new tab) |
Who each one is for, and what to know before you buy.
01Best overall
The V15 Detect is the cordless stick most homes with both carpet and hard floors should buy. Skip it only if you want a self-emptying dock, a lighter handle or a wet roller.
Pick it ifMixed carpet and hard-floor homes, including ones with shedding pets, that want the strongest measured all-round cleaning in a stick under 7 lb
Skip it ifAnyone who wants the bin emptied for them, or who cleans a lot of stairs and upholstery and would rather carry a lighter, button-operated handheld
Why it made the list. First in Vacuum Wars' cordless ranking as of September 24, 2026, and the best cordless RTINGS has tested. Highest sealed suction of the four at 124 in, a perfect carpet deep-clean score, sealed HEPA, a laser head and a particle sensor that sets power on its own, at 6.8 lb with a 0.77 L bin. The held trigger and the lack of a dock are the main complaints.
02Best budget
Buy the IP3251 if you want carpet cleaning on par with a Dyson V15 and a base that empties the bin for you. Accept a heavier handle, more noise and fewer tools in the box.
Pick it ifCarpeted homes with shedding pets whose owners want top-tier measured pickup and a self-emptying base from a mid price class
Skip it ifSmall apartments without room for a 46 in dock, or anyone who does a lot of stairs and upholstery with a 1.8 kg handle
Why it made the list. Vacuum Wars' best overall cordless of 2025 and third in its current ranking. The only pick that empties itself, into a bagless 2 L base rated for about 45 days, with 112 in of sealed suction, a perfect carpet score, sealed HEPA in vacuum and dock and 70 minutes in Eco, in a mid price class. The trade-off is a heavier, louder stick with fewer tools.
03Best premium
The V16 Submarine is for a big, mostly hard-floor home with long hair on the floor that wants Dyson's longest run time, largest bin and a wet roller in one machine. It is excellent on carpet, but not better than the V15, and it is the heaviest pick.
Pick it ifLarge homes with mostly hard floors, long-haired pets or people, and an owner who will use the compressing bin and the wet roller
Skip it ifCarpet-heavy homes, anyone sensitive to a 3.4 kg top-heavy stick, or a buyer who already owns a wet-dry floor cleaner
Why it made the list. Dyson's 2026 flagship: 315 AW on the box, 70 minutes in Eco, a lever-compressed bin that holds about 1.3 L, a cone head that feeds long hair into the bin, sealed HEPA that passed the fog test and a Submarine wet roller. It has the heaviest handle of the four (2,158 g at Vacuum Wars), its hair-tangle score was 7 of 10, and two reviewers found the V15 clears carpet more completely.
04Best for small homes and stairs
The V12 Detect Slim is the cordless to buy for an apartment, a house with stairs or anyone who finds the V15 heavy. Its small bin and weaker deep-carpet pickup make it the wrong choice for a large carpeted house.
Pick it ifSmall and mid-size homes with mostly hard floors, and anyone who wants the V15's laser, sensor and filtration in the lightest package
Skip it ifLarge carpeted houses or multi-pet homes that would fill the 0.38 L bin every session and need the V15's extra suction
Why it made the list. At 5.2 lb it keeps the V15's laser head, particle sensor and sealed filtration in a lighter body with a push button. Vacuum Wars measured 92 in of sealed suction and a 96 carpet deep-clean score. The 0.38 L bin and the standard Motorbar are the reasons to step up to the V15 in a large carpeted house.
All four picks share a sealed HEPA system, a removable battery and a brand with a US service network, and all four have been through Vacuum Wars' standard protocol, so the numbers can be set side by side. What separates them is measured suction, carpet against hard floor, real run time, weight in the hand, bin size and whether a dock does the emptying.
| Model | Sealed suction (Vacuum Wars) | Carpet deep clean (Vacuum Wars) | Run time, Eco / Max | Weight | Bin | Empties itself | Noise at Max (Vacuum Wars) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dyson V15 Detect | 124 in | 100 | 60 min / 9-11 min | 6.8 lb | 0.77 L | No | 76 dB |
| Shark PowerDetect Clean & Empty | 112 in | 100 | 70 min / 13 min | About 8 lb | 0.7 qt cup, 2 L base | Yes | 82 dB |
| Dyson V16 Piston Animal Submarine | 85 in | 100 | 70 min / 15 min | 3.4 kg (about 7.5 lb) | 0.4 L, about 1.3 L compressed | No | 74 dB |
| Dyson V12 Detect Slim | 92 in | 96 | 60 min / 8-10 min | 5.2 lb | 0.38 L | No | 85 dB |
Dyson prints 315 AW on the V16, 240 on the V15 and 150 on the V12; Shark prints no air-watt figure at all. Vacuum Wars' sealed-suction measurements rank them differently: 124 inches of water lift for the V15, 112 for the Shark, 92 for the V12 and 85 for the V16. The newest motor with the biggest number produced the lowest sealed suction of the four; Vacuum Wars' explanation is that beyond a certain point extra suction stops producing extra pickup, and the V16 gets its results from how power reaches the head. Use measured suction to rule out weak machines; between strong ones, the cleaning tests decide.
On Vacuum Wars' embedded-sand test the V15, the Shark and the V16 all scored 100 and the V12 scored 96, so all four will pull grit out of a carpet. The split is what you see on the surface after one pass. Mumsnet and CHOICE both found the V15's bristled Digital Motorbar cleared carpet more completely than the V16's twin cones, which leave a few flakes or single hairs behind along the plastic strip between them. TechGearLab measured the V12 at 78 percent on low-pile carpet and 44 percent on high pile, the weakest of the four, because it ships with the standard Motorbar. If carpet is most of your floor, the choice is between the V15 and the Shark.
The V15 and V12 pair a soft Fluffy roller with a green laser angled across the floor so fine dust shows in the beam; the V16 builds the laser into its cones and adds a separate soft roller in the Submarine box. Vacuum Wars saw near-perfect hard-floor pickup from the Dyson soft rollers and top marks from the Shark's dual-roller head, which also collects on the backstroke. The V16's Submarine roller adds wet cleaning from a 300 ml tank; Vacuum Wars scored it 131 on dried stains against a 139 category average, and CHOICE needed several passes on dried marks and refilled the tank often. Treat it as a kitchen convenience rather than a wet-dry cleaner.
Every pick has a sealed system with a HEPA-grade filter. Vacuum Wars' fog test showed no leaks from the V15, the V16 or the Shark, including the Shark's dock, and TechGearLab's particle counts came back excellent for both the V15 and the V12. A leaky vacuum blows the finest dust back into the room; check for a sealed system on any stick outside this list.
The quoted figures are Eco: 70 minutes for the V16 and the Shark, 60 for the V15 and V12, and Shark's figure is measured as a handvac. Nobody cleans a house in Eco. In Auto, where the sensors set power, Mumsnet got about 40 minutes from the V16, Vacuum Wars estimated 30 to 40 for the Shark, and independent tests put the V12 at about 30. At Max, the V16 lasted 15 minutes at Vacuum Wars, the Shark 13, the V15 9 to 11 across two tests and the V12 8 to 10. Charging runs from about 4.5 hours for the Dysons to 6 for the Shark. All four batteries clip off without tools, which matters in year four.
Vacuum Wars' handle weights: V12 1,480 g, Shark 1,804 g, V15 2,069 g, V16 2,158 g. Complete, the sticks weigh 5.2 lb, about 8 lb, 6.8 lb and 3.4 kg, roughly 7.5 lb. The V15 is the only pick that runs on a held trigger; the other three use a button. For stairs and upholstery the V12 is in a different class; for floors only, the extra weight of the V15 or Shark buys pickup.
The V15's 0.77 L bin is the largest you empty by hand every time; the V12's 0.38 L is why TechGearLab called it an apartment machine. The V16 holds 0.4 L but a lever compresses the load so about 1.3 L fits, though CHOICE found sand does not compress. The Shark is the only pick that empties itself, into a bagless 2 L base rated for about 45 days, at the cost of a dock about 46 inches tall, an emptying cycle of about 85 dB and roughly a pound more in hand than the V15. On hair, Vacuum Wars scored the V16 7 of 10 on 14-inch strands and found minimal tangling on the V12; Expert Reviews found nothing on the V15's rollers, and two multi-week Shark reviews reported rollers that looked new. Warranties: five years on the Shark vacuum, two on every Dyson.
Models we considered, and why each one did not make the list.
On April 3, 2025 the CPSC told owners of INSE S6P Pro and S6T cordless sticks to stop using them and dispose of them after 23 reports of battery packs overheating, melting or igniting, including at least 10 fires; the importer declined to agree a remedy. Combined with no US parts or service path, this tier is excluded by site policy.
Recalled through the CPSC on July 2, 2026 because the handle battery can overheat and ignite, after two US reports and 65 more worldwide. A recall with a remedy beats the INSE outcome, but it kept Rowenta off this year's list.
Our value pick without the base; Vacuum Wars ranks it ninth against the docked version's third. If you would rather empty by hand, it gets you the same head and motor.
Fifth, seventh and eighth in Vacuum Wars' ranking as of September 24, 2026. The first two are older Shark designs; the third is the lower-ranked sibling of our value pick.
The previous flagship, the first Submarine and two older models still on sale. None is in Vacuum Wars' current top ten, and the V16 covers the first two roles.
Sixth in Vacuum Wars' ranking and the closest outside contender, but we found no second independent measured test to cross-check it.
Outside this list's brand scope, with no measured results comparable to the Vacuum Wars protocol for the current models. Not a safety exclusion.
It does more: ten more minutes of Eco run time, a compressing bin, a button instead of a trigger, one head for all floors and a wet roller. It is not better on carpet; Mumsnet and CHOICE both found the V15's brush bar picked up more, and Vacuum Wars still ranks the V15 first. Buy the V16 for hard floors, long hair and run time; the V15 for carpet and weight.
Only if emptying the bin is the thing that stops you vacuuming. The Shark's base handles it for about 45 days at a time, in exchange for floor space, a burst of noise and a heavier stick. The V15's 0.77 L bin is a few seconds at the trash can.
For carpet and a shedding dog, the Shark or the V15: both scored 100 on deep cleaning and both kept their rollers clear in long-term reviews. For long hair on hard floors, the V16's cones, which fed hair into the bin for weeks at T3 and Mumsnet without a cut.
All four are regularly discounted around Prime Big Deal Days (October 6-7, 2026) and Black Friday (November 27, 2026); if either is a few weeks away, waiting is reasonable. For a machine that does the floors on its own, see our robot vacuum and mop combos.
We compared four premium and upper-mid cordless sticks from Dyson and Shark on Vacuum Wars' measured sealed suction, carpet deep-clean scores, fog-test filtration results and timed run times, with TechGearLab, RTINGS and several multi-week reviews for surface pickup and ergonomics. The short answer: the Dyson V15 Detect is still the best all-round cordless, the Shark PowerDetect Clean & Empty is the value pick and the only one that empties itself, the Dyson V16 Piston Animal Submarine is the flagship for big hard-floor homes with long hair, and the Dyson V12 Detect Slim is the one for stairs and small homes.
The shortlist was limited to Dyson and Shark, the two cordless brands with the deepest US parts and service networks, and to models Vacuum Wars has run through its standard protocol, so that sealed suction, embedded-sand carpet scores, hair-tangle results, fog-test filtration and timed run times can be set side by side. We added TechGearLab, Expert Reviews, Mumsnet, CHOICE, T3, Tech Advisor and Top Ten Reviews for surface pickup, ergonomics and multi-week notes, and RTINGS for its overall cordless ranking. We have not used these vacuums ourselves; every claim is attributed to a named test or a spec sheet. Unbranded budget sticks were excluded on battery-safety and support grounds, and models without comparable independent measurements were left out.